This is painfully accurate to how I perceived the anime.
Lucky Star was the first out of the very few animes I actually dropped, and literally the only one I gave up on after watching the first episode.
The thing I often hear fans say about Lucky Star is that it hasn't aged well and a lot of what made the jokes work was the context back in 2007.
To this day, the first episode about the Chocolate Cornet haunts my dreams.
With that said, this is much funnier (and obviously ridiculous) than the original anime in my opinion. What makes it even better is how accurate it was to my experience
Great job you guys !